ui.sh design family: disliked, cleanup deferred #35
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Recording a deferred decision from the 2026-08-05 skills triage (batch 2), so it isn't lost: we don't like the ui.sh design family, but it stays as-is for now. It's a third-party stack we don't want to mess with at this point; revisit in a later cleanup pass.
The family (9 skills):
design,componentize,add-dark-mode,dark-mode-image,make-responsive,canonicalize-tailwind,markup-from-image,ideas,brand-kit.What the triage found, for whenever this is picked back up:
design/SKILL.mdcalls itself "the complete ui.sh design guideline system";design/guidelines/assets-api.mdpoints athttps://assets.ui.sh) with no attribution or license file anywhere in the repo — a real gap for a public j4k-oss repository.ideasinjects the hardcoded remote scripthttps://ui.sh/ui-picker.jsinto the user's app — a live third-party dependency with no pin or integrity hash — and still carries vendor boilerplate ("No companion files are required.", the "Progress Updates" section).add-dark-mode,dark-mode-image, andbrand-kithard-require animagegenskill that does not exist in this repo or anywhere on the workstation (verified; it exists only as a Codex sample skill upstream), so their raster workflows cannot execute as written.brand-kitalso names a nonexistentbrand-kit-imagesskill and uses a$imagegendollar-token in prose.add-dark-moderestatesdark-mode-image's mandate in full), anddesignhas drifted from its satellites (including atext-xsfix applied on one side only).add-dark-mode,dark-mode-image,make-responsive,componentize,ideas,brand-kit; consolidate intodesign; keepcanonicalize-tailwind. That recommendation is explicitly not ruled on — the standing ruling is leave everything as-is.